A furnished vacation rental usually brings in more per month than a yearly lease on Balboa Island, but it does not always leave the owner with more. Three-bedroom leases closed at a median of $7,950 a month in the MLS over the last 18 months. Our summer monthly rates for a similar interior home run $8,950 to $16,170, yet the gap closes once you count empty winter nights and a 20% to 30% management fee.
Summer. On our published rates for October 2026, a summer month runs roughly 1.3 to 1.6 times an off-season month, and a lease gives that premium away by charging one flat rent all year. A higher-finish three- or four-bedroom near the bay lists at about $24,000 to $26,600 for a summer month, three times the median three-bedroom lease or more.
The other win is the calendar. With a yearly tenant in place, the owner gets no weeks in the house. With monthly or weekly guests, you block the weeks you want and rent the rest.
Winter, and the cost of running the house. Off-season, our three-bedroom interior homes list at $6,450 to $10,725 a month, which brackets the $7,950 lease median rather than beating it. A furnished home also does not book every night, while a tenant pays rent in February like any other month.
Costs widen the gap. Full-service vacation-rental management typically runs 20% to 30% of rent, and yearly-lease management is often under 10%. The owner of a furnished home also pays for cleaning, linens, utilities and furniture that wears faster with a new household every month.
Here is one three-bedroom interior home, priced from our rate card and the MLS lease median. On the furnished side we assume three summer months at $12,500, 90% booked, and nine off-season months at $8,500, 65% booked. For management we use 25% on the furnished side and 10% on the lease.
| Monthly furnished stays | Yearly lease | |
|---|---|---|
| Gross rent | $83,475 | $95,400 |
| Management (example rate) | $20,869 | $9,540 |
| After management | $62,606 | $85,860 |
On these assumptions the lease leaves about $23,250 more, before the furnished home's cleaning and utilities. To match the lease on gross alone, the off-season would need about 81% of its nights booked instead of 65%. The full set of income examples is on what a rental earns, and you can change any input in the rental income calculator.
Run the same test on a higher-finish home near the bay, at $25,000 a summer month and $19,000 off-season with the same booking rates, and the result flips. It grosses $178,650 and keeps about $134,000 after 25% management, against $115,020 for a median four-bedroom lease of $10,650 a month after 10%.
Most buyers are not choosing between a lease and weekly guests. Weekly stays need a city Short Term Lodging Permit, and as of October 2026 the city is not issuing new ones while active permits, 1,498 on its map on October 23, are over the 1,475 cap. Not one of the 12 properties listed for sale on the Island that day had a permit.
So for a new owner the real comparison is a yearly lease against monthly stays of 31 nights or more, which need no permit. A third shape sits between them: a lease that covers the winter, with summer kept for monthly guests or your own use. The MLS lease medians above include yearly, winter and furnished terms.
We handle both sides through our yearly rentals and our vacation rental program. For prices, permits and the rest, see the investing guide.
It depends on the house, and on how much you want to use it. A plain interior three-bedroom can keep more money on a yearly lease once management and winter vacancy are counted. A higher-finish home near the bay usually does better furnished. If you want summer weeks for yourself, a yearly lease rules that out.
In rent per month, usually. In money kept, not always. With our October 2026 rates and a 25% management fee, a three-bedroom interior home on monthly stays kept about $62,600 in our example, while a median $7,950 lease kept $85,860 after a 10% fee. The higher-finish home near the bay reversed that result.
Yes. Some Balboa Island leases run through the winter only, and the MLS lease figures we quote include them. The summer can then go to monthly guests of 31 nights or more, which need no city permit, or to your own use. Set the lease end date with room for a cleaning before the first summer guest.
Closed leases in ZIP 92662 over the last 18 months had median rents of $3,750 for one bedroom, $4,400 for two, $7,950 for three and $10,650 for four, in the MLS. Those medians mix yearly, winter and furnished leases, so treat them as a guide and ask us for comparable leases on a specific home.
The work is different. A lease is one tenant and one move-in a year. A furnished rental means a new guest every month or week, cleaning between stays, check-ins, and for short stays the city's permit conditions and the 10% lodging tax. Full-service vacation-rental management typically runs 20% to 30% of rent, against often under 10% for a lease.
We run a rental program of 48 homes and a yearly-rental side from our office on Marine Avenue, so we can price the same house both ways. Call 949.675.4822 with the address and we will set the two side by side.
Written by Abrams Coastal Properties, 315 Marine Avenue, Balboa Island. Updated October 23, 2026. Rules, rates and prices change; this is general information, not legal, tax or investment advice. Confirm permit questions with the City of Newport Beach Revenue Division at 949-718-1997.
Tell us what you are considering and we will send real numbers for the homes that fit. Or call us at 949.675.4822.