Is a Balboa Island Duplex a Better Rental?

A front house, a unit out back or upstairs, and the lot they share.

Balboa Island Duplexes

Often, yes, mainly because it costs less to get in. Two-unit homes on Balboa Island sold for a median of $3.79 million over the last 18 months in the MLS, against $4.5 million for single-family homes, and the second unit can be leased, rented by the month or kept for your own use. It still will not carry a typical mortgage on rent alone.

What a Two-Unit Lot Looks Like

Most Island lots are about 30 by 85 feet. Many hold a house in front and a second unit at the back or upstairs, and the second unit often has a "half" address, such as 208.5. Nineteen of the 66 Island sales between April 2025 and mid-October 2026 were two-unit properties, and three of the 11 homes for sale on October 23, 2026 were two-unit.

The coastal zoning code lists short-term lodging as an allowed use in the Island's R-BI district, but eligibility is decided parcel by parcel. If a two-unit home holds a permit, ask the city in writing how it applies to each unit before you close.

What Each Unit Can Earn

The small unit is the steadier earner. In the MLS over the same 18 months, one-bedroom leases on the Island closed at a median of $3,750 a month and two-bedrooms at $4,400, with yearly, winter and furnished terms mixed together. Small rear and upper units in our rental program list at about $3,800 to $5,000 for an off-season month, and those with permits at about $2,400 to $4,200 a week, on our published rates, October 2026.

The front house carries the bigger number. Three-bedroom leases closed at a median of $7,950 a month, and three-bedroom interior homes we rent by the month list at $8,950 to $16,170 for a summer month.

A Worked Example

Take a duplex at the $3.79 million median with a two-bedroom rear unit and a three-bedroom front house, both leased at the MLS medians. That is $4,400 plus $7,950, or $12,350 a month and $148,200 a year before any expense.

With 25% down, the loan is $2,842,500. At an example rate of 6.75% over 30 years the payment is about $18,436 a month, or $221,237 a year. Property tax at 1.05% to 1.2% adds about $39,800 to $45,500. The rent covers about two-thirds of the loan payment, before tax, insurance or upkeep. Renting the front house by the month in summer narrows that gap but does not close it.

Try your own mix in the rental income calculator, and see financing a rental here for other down payments.

Three Ways to Run One

  • Lease the small unit by the year and rent the front house by the month in summer, 31 nights or longer, when rates run roughly 1.3 to 1.6 times off-season. See monthly rentals.
  • Keep one unit for your own visits and rent the other.
  • Rent both by the month. At 31 nights or more, neither needs a city permit.

Weekly rentals need an active city permit, and as of October 2026 the city is not issuing new ones. If a two-unit home already has one, check it with the Revenue Division at 949-718-1997 before you write an offer.

The Trade-Offs

Each unit is smaller than a single-unit house on the same lot. Two units mean two kitchens to keep up and, if both are furnished, two sets of turnovers. Full-service management for furnished rentals typically runs 20% to 30% of the rent, far more than for a yearly lease, so a split plan with one leased unit keeps that cost down. Our rental investing guide covers permits and prices in more depth.

Questions We Hear

How much does a duplex cost on Balboa Island?

Nineteen two-unit properties sold on the Island between April 2025 and mid-October 2026, at a median of $3.79 million (CRMLS). Single-unit homes sold for a median of $4.5 million over the same stretch. On October 23, 2026, three of the 11 homes for sale were two-unit.

Can I live in one unit and rent out the other?

Yes, within city rules. Renting the other unit for 31 nights or longer needs no short-term lodging permit, and a yearly lease is the simplest arrangement of all. Renting it by the week needs an active city permit, and the city is not issuing new ones as of October 2026.

What does a back unit on Balboa Island rent for?

Over 18 months in the MLS, one-bedroom leases on the Island closed at a median of $3,750 a month and two-bedrooms at $4,400, across yearly, winter and furnished terms. Small units in our rental program list at about $3,800 to $5,000 for an off-season month.

Can both units of a duplex get short-term permits?

Ask the city, parcel by parcel. Balboa Island's zoning allows short-term lodging, but new permits are not being issued while the city is over its 1,475 cap, and none of the 12 properties for sale on October 23, 2026 held one. Get the answer in writing from the Revenue Division before you rely on it.

Does a duplex cash-flow on Balboa Island?

Rarely with a mortgage. Leasing both units of a $3.79 million duplex at the MLS medians brings in about $148,200 a year, while a 25% down loan at an example 6.75% rate costs about $221,237 a year before property tax. A duplex narrows the shortfall compared with a single-unit home.

Sources

Written by Abrams Coastal Properties, 315 Marine Avenue, Balboa Island. Updated October 23, 2026. Rules, rates and prices change; this is general information, not legal, tax or investment advice. Confirm permit questions with the City of Newport Beach Revenue Division at 949-718-1997.

Questions

Ask Us About a Balboa Island Rental

Tell us what you are considering and we will send real numbers for the homes that fit. Or call us at 949.675.4822.

Thinking About Balboa Island?

Talk to a team that works these neighborhoods every day.