Which Balboa Island Homes Make the Best Rentals?

Every home for sale on the Island, looked at as a rental.

Homes for Sale, Ranked as Rentals

On October 23, 2026, 12 properties were for sale on Balboa Island in the MLS, from $3,195,000 to $12,995,000, and none of them held a Newport Beach short-term lodging permit. So we rank them on what they could earn rented by the month, 31 nights or longer, which needs no permit. Two-unit lots near the water come out on top, led by 121 Marine Avenue. Three of these homes are our own listings, and we mark them.

The order is by estimated monthly-rental income as a share of the asking price. It is a starting point for questions, not a recommendation to buy. Prices and availability change every week, and each address links to its live listing.

The List

121 Marine Avenue, Balboa Island

1. 121 Marine Avenue, $3,490,000. Two units, 3 bedrooms (two units: 2 bd and 1 bd), 1,633 sq ft, built 1932. A remodeled duplex in the 100 block of Marine Avenue: a two-bedroom cottage in front and a one-bedroom unit upstairs in back.

Estimated rent on monthly stays of 31+ nights: about $142,500 a year, or 4.1% of the asking price. On a yearly lease: about $93,900. Short-term permit: none on the city map. Run the numbers.

MLS# NP26173625. Listing courtesy of Abrams Coastal Properties. This is one of our listings.

224 Coral, Balboa Island

2. 224 Coral, $5,650,000. Single-family, 4 bedrooms, 3,363 sq ft, built 1990. In the 200 block of Coral. This home is in our rental program now at $25,850 for a summer month and $23,350 off-season (published October 2026), so we used those rates instead of the model.

Estimated rent on monthly stays of 31+ nights: about $206,400 a year, or 3.6% of the asking price. On a yearly lease: about $122,700. Short-term permit: none on the city map. Run the numbers.

MLS# NP26184045. Listing courtesy of Abrams Coastal Properties. This is one of our listings.

122 Agate, Balboa Island

3. 122 Agate, $3,195,000. Mixed-use, 3 bedrooms, 3,026 sq ft, built 1937. A mixed-use building near the ferry: a shop downstairs and a three-bedroom apartment upstairs, leased long-term. Short-term lodging rules for mixed-use zoning are different, so we have not assumed any.

Estimated rent on monthly stays of 31+ nights: about $113,300 a year, or 3.5% of the asking price. On a yearly lease: about $91,600. Short-term permit: none on the city map. Run the numbers.

MLS# NP26160842. Listing courtesy of Abrams Coastal Properties. This is one of our listings.

330 Onyx Avenue, Balboa Island

4. 330 Onyx Avenue, $7,990,000. Single-family, 4 bedrooms, 3,300 sq ft, built 2023. In the 300 block of Onyx, just off Marine Avenue. Elevator, roof deck and a three-car garage.

Estimated rent on monthly stays of 31+ nights: about $222,500 a year, or 2.8% of the asking price. On a yearly lease: about $122,700. Short-term permit: none on the city map. Run the numbers.

MLS# OC26098230. Listing courtesy of Compass.

209 Diamond Avenue, Balboa Island

5. 209 Diamond Avenue, $4,295,000. Single-family, 3 bedrooms, 1,550 sq ft, built 1994. In the 200 block of Diamond, mid-island. The listing describes a fully redone interior.

Estimated rent on monthly stays of 31+ nights: about $118,400 a year, or 2.8% of the asking price. On a yearly lease: about $91,600. Short-term permit: none on the city map. Run the numbers.

MLS# OC26221485. Listing courtesy of The Oppenheim Group.

327 Amethyst, Balboa Island

6. 327 Amethyst, $7,495,000. Two units, 4 bedrooms (two units: 3 bd and 1 bd), 3,479 sq ft, built 1968. Three doors from the bay, remodeled, with a one-bedroom junior unit in back.

Estimated rent on monthly stays of 31+ nights: about $182,800 a year, or 2.4% of the asking price. On a yearly lease: about $134,800. Short-term permit: none on the city map. Run the numbers.

MLS# NP26201140. Listing courtesy of Arbor Real Estate.

1407 N Bay Front, Balboa Island

7. 1407 N Bay Front, $9,495,000. Two units, 4 bedrooms, 2,003 sq ft, built 1951. Two units on a wide North Bay Front lot (45 feet of frontage) with its own pier and dock. The listing does not give the unit split, so we figured it as one four-bedroom home.

Estimated rent on monthly stays of 31+ nights: about $216,700 a year, or 2.3% of the asking price. On a yearly lease: about $122,700. Short-term permit: none on the city map. Run the numbers.

MLS# NP26070161. Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Realty.

113 Grand Canal, Balboa Island

8. 113 Grand Canal, $10,995,000. Single-family, 4 bedrooms, 2,501 sq ft, built 2026. New construction on the Grand Canal.

Estimated rent on monthly stays of 31+ nights: about $222,500 a year, or 2.0% of the asking price. On a yearly lease: about $122,700. Short-term permit: none on the city map. Run the numbers.

MLS# NP26176731. Listing courtesy of Christie's International R.E. Southern California.

119 Opal, Balboa Island

9. 119 Opal, $5,799,000. Single-family, 3 bedrooms, 2,354 sq ft, built 2001. A few doors off South Bay Front, with a roof deck.

Estimated rent on monthly stays of 31+ nights: about $113,300 a year, or 1.9% of the asking price. On a yearly lease: about $91,600. Short-term permit: none on the city map. Run the numbers.

MLS# PW26210356. Listing courtesy of Balboa Island Estates.

409 North Bayfront, Balboa Island

10. 409 North Bayfront, $12,495,000. Single-family, 3 bedrooms, 2,429 sq ft, built 2019. On North Bay Front. The listing mentions a mooring opportunity offshore.

Estimated rent on monthly stays of 31+ nights: about $216,400 a year, or 1.7% of the asking price. On a yearly lease: about $91,600. Short-term permit: none on the city map. Run the numbers.

MLS# NP26228173. Listing courtesy of Arbor Real Estate.

1105 N Bay Front, Balboa Island

11. 1105 N Bay Front, $12,995,000. Single-family, 3 bedrooms, 2,389 sq ft, built 2026. New construction on North Bay Front.

Estimated rent on monthly stays of 31+ nights: about $216,400 a year, or 1.7% of the asking price. On a yearly lease: about $91,600. Short-term permit: none on the city map. Run the numbers.

MLS# NP26184232. Listing courtesy of Pacific Sotheby's Int'l Realty.

302 Ruby Avenue, Balboa Island

12. 302 Ruby Avenue, $5,200,000. Single-family, 2 bedrooms, 2,415 sq ft, built 1993. In the 300 block of Ruby. Two bedrooms plus a den.

Estimated rent on monthly stays of 31+ nights: about $78,400 a year, or 1.5% of the asking price. On a yearly lease: about $50,700. Short-term permit: none on the city map. Run the numbers.

MLS# NP26219910. Listing courtesy of Surterre Properties Inc..

CRMLS

Based on information from California Regional Multiple Listing Service, Inc. as of October 23, 2026. All data, including all measurements and calculations of area, is obtained from various sources and has not been, and will not be, verified by broker or MLS. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some properties shown may have since sold or changed price. The information is for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.

How We Estimated the Rent

Off-season monthly rates come from a simple model fitted to our own published Balboa Island rates (October 2026), adjusted for bedrooms, how close the home is to the bay, and whether it is new, remodeled or original. Summer months are figured at 1.4 times the off-season rate. We assume three summer months rented 90% of the time and nine off-season months rented 65% of the time. Where a home is already in our rental program, we use its published rates instead.

Yearly-lease figures use median closed leases in ZIP 92662 by bedroom count from the MLS, April 2025 to October 2026: $3,750 for one bedroom, $4,400 for two, $7,950 for three and $10,650 for four, rented 96% of the year.

These are gross figures, before management, cleaning, utilities, property tax, insurance and any loan. A purchase near the $4.375 million median with 25% down at an example 6.75% rate has loan payments of about $255,000 a year, more than any estimate on this page. Try any home in the rental income calculator to see the full year.

About Permits

We checked every address against the city's map of active short-term lodging permits on October 23, 2026. None matched. The city caps permits at 1,475 and is not issuing new ones while active permits (1,498 that day) are over the cap. A permit can pass to a buyer only if it is active and the buyer files with the city within 60 days of title transfer, so a home has to have one before you can take it over. More in how permit transfers work and how monthly rentals work.

Left Off the List

  • A one-eighth fractional co-ownership share at 305 Grand Canal. It is a share with its own use rules, not a whole property you can rent.
  • A retail business-opportunity listing, which is a business, not real estate.
  • Two duplicate MLS entries for homes already on the list.

Questions We Hear

Are there any Balboa Island homes for sale with a short-term rental permit?

Not on October 23, 2026. We checked all 12 properties for sale against the city permit map and none had an active permit. Permitted homes do sell from time to time. When one does, the buyer has to file with the city within 60 days of title transfer to keep the permit.

Which Balboa Island homes for sale would make the best rentals?

On monthly-rental income as a share of price, 121 Marine Avenue, 224 Coral and 122 Agate led our list on October 23, 2026. Two-unit lots near the water score well because both units can earn. 122 Agate, 121 Marine Avenue and 224 Coral are our own listings.

How much do Balboa Island investment properties cost?

The properties on this list ask from $3,195,000 to $12,995,000. Over the last 18 months, 66 homes and duplexes sold on the Island at a median of $4.375 million in the MLS. Duplexes had a median of $3.79 million and single-family homes $4.5 million.

How did you estimate the rent?

From our own published Balboa Island rates for monthly stays, adjusted for bedrooms, distance to the bay and condition, with summer at 1.4 times the off-season rate. We assume summer months are rented 90% of the time and off-season months 65%. Yearly-lease figures are MLS median leases by bedroom count.

Will the rent pay the mortgage on these homes?

Not with a typical loan. The highest estimate on this page is far below the roughly $255,000 a year in payments on a $4.375 million purchase with 25% down at an example 6.75% rate. Buyers who want the numbers to work put much more down or pay cash.

How can Abrams Coastal help me buy a rental on Balboa Island?

We sell homes on the Island from our office at 315 Marine Avenue and run a rental program of 48 homes, so we can look at a house as a purchase and as a rental at once and check its permit status with the city. Call 949.675.4822.

Sources

Written by Abrams Coastal Properties, 315 Marine Avenue, Balboa Island. Updated October 23, 2026. Rules, rates and prices change; this is general information, not legal, tax or investment advice. Confirm permit questions with the City of Newport Beach Revenue Division at 949-718-1997.

Questions

Ask About One of These Homes

Tell us which home and we will send what we know about it. Or call us at 949.675.4822.

Thinking About Balboa Island?

Talk to a team that works these neighborhoods every day.