For short-term rentals, Balboa Island has the clearer path on paper. On October 23, 2026, the city's permit map showed 240 active permits on Balboa Island and 97 in Corona del Mar Village, largely because much of Corona del Mar is zoned R-1, where Newport Beach does not allow short-term lodging. Neither area can get a new permit right now, and for monthly or yearly tenants the two are much closer.
It is mostly zoning. Balboa Island has its own residential district, R-BI, and the city's coastal zoning code lists short-term lodging as an allowed use there. Much of Corona del Mar is R-1, single-unit zoning, where short-term lodging is off the table unless the use was legally established by June 1, 2004. Short-term lodging is also allowed in R-1.5, R-2 and RM zones, which is where a Corona del Mar permit is likely to sit.
None of that settles a particular house. Eligibility is decided parcel by parcel, and the city has an address lookup on its site. Run it before you run any rental numbers. Our Corona del Mar page covers the village itself.
As of October 2026 the city caps residential short-term permits at 1,475. We counted 1,498 active ones on its map, so no new permits are being handed out in either place. The waitlist had 817 names on it, and you can only join if you own a property zoned for short-term lodging.
That leaves buying a home that already holds one. The city's transfer page is plain about it: permits do not move with a title change on their own. It has to be active and compliant, and you file as the buyer within 60 days of title transfer. Miss that window and you risk losing the permit with no way back in but the waitlist. Of the 12 properties listed on the Island that same day, not one had a permit. Details are on our permit transfer page, and the city's Revenue Division (949-718-1997) will confirm the status of any address.
Rent to someone for 31 nights or more and you need no short-term permit in either place, R-1 or not. That is our advice on the length, since the city FAQ says 30 days or less is short-term while the code says less than 30. Stays that long also skip the 10% lodging tax.
On the Island, our published monthly-only rates for a three-bedroom interior home, summer months bring $8,950 to $16,170 and the off-season $6,450 to $10,725. Three- and four-bedroom homes near the bay with a higher finish list at about $24,000 to $26,600 in summer. For comparison, Island leases in the MLS over the last 18 months had a median of $7,950 a month for three bedrooms and $10,650 for four, across mixed lease terms. More on renting by the month.
Our sales data covers Balboa Island only. Over the last 12 months 48 homes and duplexes sold there at a median of $4.03 million in the MLS. Over 18 months, two-unit lots had a $3.79 million median and single-family homes $4.5 million, which matters if you want one unit to rent and one to use.
We will not guess at Corona del Mar prices from here. Give us an address and we will pull the comps. Either way, the rent rarely pays a mortgage at these prices. Borrow 75% of a $4.375 million price at an example 6.75% and the payments come to roughly $255,000 a year. Run a real Island listing through the rental income calculator, and see our rental investing guide for the wider picture.
Balboa Island, if the goal is nightly or weekly guests. It held 240 active city permits on October 23, 2026 against 97 in Corona del Mar Village, because its R-BI zoning allows short-term lodging and much of Corona del Mar is single-unit R-1. You still need a house that already holds a permit, since the city is not issuing new ones.
Only if the parcel's zoning allows it and the home holds an active city permit you can transfer. In R-1 zones, short-term lodging is not allowed unless it was legally established by June 1, 2004. Look up the address with the city and confirm with the Revenue Division before you write an offer.
Yes, stays longer than 30 days fall outside the short-term lodging rules, so they need no city permit in any zone. We suggest 31 nights or more to stay clear of the difference in the city's wording. Yearly leases work the same way.
We can only show Island numbers. Our published monthly rates for a three-bedroom interior home run $8,950 to $16,170 in summer, against a $7,950 median monthly lease for three bedrooms in the MLS. For a Corona del Mar home we would need to pull comparable rents for that block, which we are glad to do.
Seldom with a loan. A typical Island purchase financed with 25% down runs about $255,000 a year in payments at an example 6.75% rate, well above what a typical home here rents for. Buyers who make the numbers work generally put much more down or pay cash. Ask your CPA how the income would be taxed.
Written by Abrams Coastal Properties, 315 Marine Avenue, Balboa Island. Updated October 23, 2026. Rules, rates and prices change; this is general information, not legal, tax or investment advice. Confirm permit questions with the City of Newport Beach Revenue Division at 949-718-1997.
Tell us what you are considering and we will send real numbers for the homes that fit. Or call us at 949.675.4822.