The Peninsula is the bigger short-term rental market and Balboa Island the more concentrated one. On the city's permit map on October 23, 2026, Central Newport, Newport Village and Peninsula Point held about 621 active permits to Balboa Island's 240, with 455 more in West Newport. Both sit under the same Newport Beach cap of 1,475, and neither side can get a new permit today, so the choice comes down to the house.
We pulled the active short-term lodging permits off the city's own map on October 23, 2026. Here is how the two sides of the harbor stack up.
| Area on the city map | Active permits |
|---|---|
| Central Newport | 305 |
| Newport Village | 248 |
| Peninsula Point | 68 |
| Peninsula, together | about 621 |
| West Newport | 455 |
| Balboa Island | 240 |
| Newport Beach, all areas | 1,498 |
Add West Newport and the ocean side of town holds about 1,076 permits, roughly four and a half times the Island's count. Still, 240 permits on three small islands is about one in six of every active permit in the city. More permits on the Peninsula also means more permitted homes competing for the same summer weeks.
The rules do not change when you take the ferry from Agate Avenue. As of October 2026, a stay of 30 days or less anywhere in Newport Beach needs a Short Term Lodging Permit, a city business license and transient occupancy tax registration. Guests pay 10% of the rent in lodging tax. The city sets a two-night minimum, bars renting to anyone under 25, and wants the permit number in every ad and a local contact who can respond within 30 minutes, day or night.
Zoning is where a given house passes or fails. Short-term lodging is allowed in R-1.5, R-2 and RM zones and in the Island's own R-BI district. It is not allowed in R-1 single-unit zones unless the use was legally established on or before June 1, 2004. The Peninsula has a mix, so check each address on the city's lookup. It also has a separate pool of 75 permits in two mixed-use districts (MU-W2 and the 15th Street area), but those are only for owners of 20 or more units there.
More detail on how the city permit works.
No new permits are going out while the active count, 1,498 on our count, sits above the 1,475 residential cap. Its waitlist had 817 entries citywide, 19 of them with a 92662 address. So on both sides of the harbor the permit comes with the house or not at all.
A transfer is possible but not automatic. The permit must be active and compliant, and the buyer has to file within 60 days of title transfer. See how permit transfers work. Not one of the 12 Island properties on the market on October 23, 2026 had a permit. On the Peninsula, look the address up on the same city map before you count on a single weekly booking.
Without a permit, rent by the month. We book monthly guests for 31 nights or more on either side, which needs no permit and carries no lodging tax. See monthly rentals.
We sell and manage rentals on Balboa Island, so that is the only side we price here. In the MLS, 48 Island homes and duplexes sold over the last 12 months at a median of $4.03 million. On our published rates, a three-bedroom on the bay front rents for about $5,300 to $10,400 a week with a permit.
We do not publish Peninsula prices. If you are weighing a Peninsula house, ask us and we will pull recent sales for those blocks. AirDNA puts the average active listing across all of Newport Beach at about $98,000 a year through June 2026, but that blends both sides, every size of home, and monthly listings too.
On either side, rent rarely covers a large loan. At $4.375 million with 25% down and an example rate of 6.75%, payments run about $255,000 a year. Try your own numbers in the rental income calculator, or start with our guide to Island rental investing.
By permit count, the Peninsula and West Newport, which held about 1,076 of the city's 1,498 active short-term permits on October 23, 2026. Balboa Island held 240. But the city is not issuing new permits anywhere while it is over its 1,475 cap, so the best place is wherever you find a house with an active, transferable permit.
About 621 on the city's permit map on October 23, 2026: 305 in Central Newport, 248 in Newport Village and 68 at Peninsula Point. West Newport, along the same stretch of ocean, had 455 more.
Not as of October 2026. The Peninsula falls under the same citywide cap of 1,475 residential permits as Balboa Island, and the city says it will not issue new ones until the active count drops below the cap. You can join the waitlist if you own an eligible property. Confirm with the Revenue Division at 949-718-1997.
We only publish Balboa Island figures, so we will not guess. On the Island, 66 homes and duplexes sold from April 2025 to mid-October 2026 at a median of $4.375 million in the MLS. Call us and we will pull Peninsula sales for the streets you are looking at.
The city rules are identical: same permit, same 10% lodging tax on stays of 30 days or less, same two-night minimum. What differs is the house in front of you, its zoning and whether it already holds a permit. Our own rental program asks for a 7-night minimum in peak season, which is our policy, not the city's.
Our office is on Marine Avenue, a ferry ride from the Peninsula, and we run a rental program of 48 homes besides selling houses. We can check the permit and zoning on any address on either side and price an Island home as a rental. Call 949.675.4822.
Written by Abrams Coastal Properties, 315 Marine Avenue, Balboa Island. Updated October 23, 2026. Rules, rates and prices change; this is general information, not legal, tax or investment advice. Confirm permit questions with the City of Newport Beach Revenue Division at 949-718-1997.
Tell us what you are considering and we will send real numbers for the homes that fit. Or call us at 949.675.4822.